Internet Mathematics goes arXiv overlay

Internet Mathematics is a journal devoted to complex networks, and was founded by Fan Chung Graham in 2003. Research on complex networks is fast-breaking and interdisciplinary, and the journal provides a forum for high quality articles on the topic. The journal was published in four to six volumes a year, was originally published by AK Peters, and then moved to Taylor & Francis (who acquired the latter). I became co-editor-in-chief of the journal in 2010, and have been the sole editor-in-chief since 2015 (with Fan remaining on as founding editor).

We received news in July 2016 that Taylor & Francis would not be publishing Internet Mathematics as January 1, 2017. This news came as shock, as the journal was doing well with number of submissions and their quality. Talking it over with Fan and others, it was decided that we could continue Internet Mathematics, as it provides such a valuable resource for researchers in complex networks.

The journal Discrete Analysis inspired us to consider an arXiv overlay format for the future of the journal. In this model of academic publishing, papers are posted to the preprint server arXiv, and then submitted to IM through an on-line portal run by Scholastica. If a paper is accepted, then the journal links to it on arXiv. However, accepted papers do not go through the usual production phase after revisions; no formatting is required by the journal, and we do not ask authors to transfer of copyright. This makes the process faster that traditionally published journals and gives authors very strong control over their own work. There is a small fee of $10 per submission charged by Scholastica, and Discrete Analysis absorbs that cost. Through support of the Department of Mathematics at Ryerson University, Internet Mathematics will do the same. Hence, we have the important caveat: Submissions to Internet Mathematics will remain free for authors.

What active researchers really want is access to a particular paper, and the arXiv overlay format makes access to papers (most of which are already posted to arXiv) incredibly quick and direct. Think of the arXiv overlay model as an electronic journal, which lets authors keep rights to their work. We will maintain the same high standards of refereeing, and accepted papers will be revised just as in regular journals. Note that arXiv, of course, allows you to update your paper. One advantage is that authors can adjust or correct their papers well after the paper is “published” on our website.

Internet Mathematics will continue to be indexed on MathSciNet, Zentralbatt, and Scopus, and will retain its ISSN. Papers will also be assigned a unique DOI. Further, with generous support of the Faculty of Science at Ryerson University, we have purchased the archive of all previous IM volumes. Taylor & Francis will use a redirect to our new site (which is under production), which will contain everything related to the journal. I’ll continue in my role as editor-in-chief, with the help of managing editors Nelly Litvak and Aris Gionis. We are excited to also add Pawel Pralat as a new managing editor.

While I think that traditionally published journals will remain for quite some time, the arXiv overlay model is the way of the future. Ultimately, we are academics focused on quality research, rather than the profit motive tied with traditional publishers. Quality refereeing of academic papers will remain extremely important, regardless of the model used for publication. Papers will continue to be curated within journals that serve specific research communities. Time will tell how the community reacts to now having two arXiv overlay journals in mathematics.

Anthony Bonato

One thought on “Internet Mathematics goes arXiv overlay

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s